Photo by Artyom Korshunov/Unsplash

Bureau of Land Management (BLM) officials have rejected efforts to construct a 211-mile road to the Ambler mining district in Northwest Alaska, citing the critical need of Alaska Native communities along the Brooks Range for sustainable wildlife habitat and clean waters. 

The BLM’s analysis, released on June 28, found that the proposed Ambler Road would have required over 3,000 stream crossings and would have impacted at-risk wildlife, including sheefish and the declining Western Arctic caribou herd, both critical food sources for Native communities. The analysis found that the road would have reduced the abundance and availability of subsistence resources while also restricting access to them. 

The analysis also found irreparable impacts to permafrost would make it unlikely the road could be reclaimed and that it is reasonably foreseeable that the industrial road would be used by the public, increasing impacts to the surrounding area and communities. 

The supplemental environmental impact statement was prepared to address deficiencies identified in the 2020 analysis that resulted in a remand from the federal district court. The new analysis evaluated the same range of alternatives and routes as the 2020 EIS, but more thoroughly analyzed potential impacts to resources — including subsistence impacts under Section 810 of the Alaska National Interest Lands Conservation Act (ANILCA). The analysis of Section 810 found that more than 60 Alaska Native communities would experience restrictions on their subsistence and, of those, over 30 would experience significant restriction of subsistence uses if the road was constructed. 

Interior Secretary Deb Haaland said that the Department of the Interior takes seriously its obligations to manage America’s public lands for the benefit of all people.  

“In Alaska, that includes ensuring that we consider the impacts of proposed actions on Alaska Native and rural subsistence users,” Haaland said. “Guided by feedback from tribal nations, Native corporations and the best-available science, the steps we are taking today ensure these important areas remain intact for generations to come.” 

Advertisement

Environmental entities voiced strong approval for the BLM’s decision, while the Alaska congressional delegation was soundly critical. 

Sens. Lisa Murkowski and Dan Sullivan, both R-Alaska, and Rep. Mary Peltola, D-Alaska, condemned 

the decision, saying that a private haul road would provide economic benefits in Alaska and facilitate domestic supplies of key minerals. 

Murkowski noted nine years of federal permitting with access to minerals essential for everything from clean energy to national security. She cited it as “a rare opportunity for development in rural Alaska under the highest standards, so we don’t have to import from unstable nations that have no protections for people or the environment.” Murkowski contended that the BLM had ignored federal law, national vulnerabilities and Alaska’s record of responsible development, all in the name of election year politics. 

Sullivan called the minerals “critically important.”  

“These minerals are critically important for our national defense, economy, and renewable energy sector. ANILCA mandates the right-of-way for this road,” he said. “Career professional staff from the Obama and Trump administrations studied and then approved it after several years. Consultations with Alaskan stakeholder groups were extensive and far-reaching.” 

Peltola said the decision contradicted ANILCA.  

“All too often, promises made to Alaska Natives by Congress haven’t been kept,” Peltola said. “There’s a path forward where local buy-in for this project is real and sustainable.”  

Peltola said the delegation would seek to affirm permanent private road that would “make these resources available in a way that works for stakeholders in the area.” 

Opponents of the Ambler Road meanwhile saw the decision as a way that would work well for subsistence stakeholders in the area. 

“We are thankful the administration listened to those who know the Brooks Range best,” said Suzanne Bostrom, senior staff attorney with Trustees for Alaska, the Anchorage law firm representing organizations who challenged the original court decision on the Ambler Road. “This outcome is the result of years of advocacy in and out of court on the part of Tribes and local communities, as well as Alaskans and state and national groups who uplifted this Arctic region’s importance to people, caribou, clean water, and future generations.”  

The Wilderness Society said that the BLM’s decision against building a road across the Brooks Range and Gates of the Arctic National Park and Preserve effectively killed a controversial project that would have allowed the mining industry to do environmentally destructive development and threaten subsistence resources for the region’s remote communities. This action shows that President Joe Biden’s administration is making bold moves to protect Alaska Native communities and strengthen conservation across a broad swath of our state, said Meda DeWitt, interim Alaska director of the Wilderness Society. 

United Tribes of Bristol Bay and others noted that the BLM’s broader action also took a big step toward finalizing protections for a total of 28 million acres of federally managed lands identified. The review was prompted by outgoing former President Donald Trump Administration’s threat to open those lands up for extractive mineral development.  

Section D-1 of the Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act (ANCSA) authorized the Interior Secretary to recommend to Congress designation of up to 80 million acres of Alaska land for use as national parks, forests and refuges and for inclusion of some of Alaska’s rivers in the Wild and Scenic Rivers System. 

Rachel James, public lands and waters lead for SalmonState, applauded the Interior Department’s decision — saying it supports more than half of Alaska’s 227 federally recognized tribal governments, as well as more than 120 businesses and 145,000 Alaskans and Americans. She urged Haaland to finalize these safeguards for Alaska’s D-1 lands as soon as possible. 

“The BLM final environmental impact statement makes it clear that we must retain protections on all 28 million acres of D-1 lands in Alaska,” said Alannah Hurley, executive director of United Tribes of Bristol Bay. “The majority of the federally recognized Tribes in Alaska have voiced support for protecting these critical lands. Lifting protections on these lands will dramatically harm the health and wellbeing of our Tribal communities and threaten the continued vitality of our sacred ways of life.” 

Sophie Swope, executive director of the Mother Kuskokwim tribal entity in Bethel, echoed similar concerns.  

“D-1 lands in the Yukon-Kuskokwim region are vital to our people’s way of life,” Swope said. “These protections ensure future generations will be able to live safely with and on the land, carrying our customary and traditional knowledge.” 

The Norton Bay Watershed Council in Nome also praised the BLM decision to protect D-1 lands. The council spent two years participating in the BLM environmental review process and provided input on how the 13 million-acre Bering Sea Western Interior and Kobuck-Seward lands under review are of critical importance to their way of life.  

“BLM has recognized potential D-1 withdrawal lands that possess and serve as culturally significant subsistence and sacred areas for Tribes who live on or near these areas,” said Emily Murray, vice president of the Norton Bay Watershed Council. “These vital tributary and ecosystems provide habitat and protection for moose, salmon and migratory birds our subsistence economy depends on. As Tribes seeking grants for necessary infrastructure, we are listed as ‘economically disadvantaged.’ Therefore, we highly depend on our subsistence activities for the health and well-being of our Tribe as a whole.” 

Advertisement